DIY Knock Sensor vs High End Knock Sensor (Audio Comparison)

Here is an audio comparison of a high level knock sensor system that costs hundreds of dollars vs a DIY knock sensor system that costs less than $5.

The DIY knock sensor system in the video can be made by most people for less than $5. This DIY knock sensor system outputs audio only in real time (there could be a small delay depending on your laptop, less than half a second in my experience). You can also choose to record the audio for playback later if you wish.

In this article I will detail how you can make this DIY knock sensor.


What the DIY knock sensor can’t do

No visuals, connection to external ECUs, datalogging.

Aftermarket knock sensor systems cost from a few hundred dollars to a thousand or more dollars.

There is a reason for this.

These systems will generally seek to autmoate the knock sensing process which means they will give the user a visual indiciation of knock eg a LED and they could also send a signal to the engine’s ECU which will indicate knock, the more expensive systems may even vary the voltage going to the engine ECU to show the severity of the knock.


What the DIY knock sensor can do

Allow you to listen to engine knock in realtime, (or very close to real time) and also give you the ability to record the audio from the knock sensor for playback later, if you wish.

It does not do anything else.

If you need a visual indication of knock, if you need to send a signal to an ECU to indicate knock, if you want to datalog or anything else, the only option I know of, would be to purchase an aftermarket knock sensor system. There is no easy DIY solution for these features.


What you need to buy to make a DIY knock sensor

You only need to buy two things (okay, maybe four)

1. A bare male mic jack and

2.Three mteres (ish) of mono mic cable.


3&4 If you think your knock sensor will be outputting more than 2 volts at peak output, you should make a voltage divider to reduce the voltage going to your laptop’s mic socket. Parts 3 and 4 will be the resistors you need. If you are not sure if you need a voltage divider, put a multimeter on the knock sensor output to measure it.


Other (free) things you need

-APO Equalizer Software

-VLC Media Player Software

-The ability to tap into the factory knock sensor. A positap is what I recommend but if you want something cheaper, splice crimps will work also, even if they can be a bit unreliable.

-Headphones

-Laptop with mic and headphone sockets


How To Build Your DIY Knock Sensor

1.Wire your headphone jack to your mic cable (3 meters length should be enough) and run the cable from the laptop to your existing knock sensor (positive and negative cables) – Jack Wiring diagram is here if you need it.

Insert your voltage divider on the positive wire, if you are using one.

2.Tap the wires coming from your mic jack cable into your existing knock sensor cables using the positap or whatever method you chose.

3.Download and install APO Equalizer and VLC Media Player.

4.Find the knock frequency of your engine, using a knock frequency calculator

5.Plug the jack on your knock sensor cable into the mic input on your laptop

6.Open APO Equaliser and customise the equalizer so it enhances the knock frequency +/- 400hz and reduces all other frequencies.

For exmaple, if your knock frequency is 7200hz. Enhance the levels from 6800hz to 7600hz and reduce the input from 7601hz and up, and from 6799hz and down. You only want to hear noises in the 6800hz to 7600hz frequency range.

You can obviously customise these ranges, frequencies and levels if you need to.

How the APO Equaliser settings look when increasing the levels at the knock frequency and reducing the levels on all other frequencies

7.Open VLC media player and select the capture device as “Microphone” and press “Play”.

8. Connect and wear your headphones

You are now listening to the knock sensor output in real time.

Adjust the gain the APO Equalizer software to get the volume you need.

The beauty of this solution is that you can listen to the knock sensor signal in the background while you use the laptop for other things eg tuning the engine.

Remember

There could be a slight delay in hearing the engine sounds. You may need to adjust frequencies. You may need to reduce the voltage going into your laptop’s mic socket.

The next level

If you need more features such as visual indications, knock signals for ECUs, permanent installation or datalogging then the next step would be to buy an off the shelf knock detection solution.

The DIY knock sensor is purely for hearing engine knock, nothing more.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

sixteen − ten =